For anyone tracing their Irish ancestry, selecting the right type of DNA test – autosomal, Y-DNA or mtDNA – and the right testing company is crucial for uncovering both recent family connections and understanding your origins.
DNA testing has become an increasingly popular tool for exploring genealogy. For those with Irish roots, it can complement traditional genealogical research, uncovering unknown family connections and providing insights into ancestral origins and movements. Picking the right test requires careful consideration. Each type of DNA test provides different information, and its perceived value depends on your specific research goals and on which line or lines of your family tree you are investigating. The choice of testing company also matters, since its database size, its analytical tools and its availability and popularity in specific regions can impact the quality and usefulness of your results.
A D V E R T I S E M E N T
Understanding the different types of DNA tests
There are three main types of DNA tests used in genealogical research: autosomal DNA, Y-chromosome DNA and mitochondrial DNA. Each type of test has its strengths and limitations.
Autosomal DNA tests for Irish genealogical research
Autosomal DNA (atDNA) tests are the most widely used type of DNA test for genealogical research, with around 40 million people worldwide having undergone testing. Both males and females can take autosomal tests. This test analyzes the 22 pairs of non-sex chromosomes inherited from both parents, providing a balanced view of recent ancestry across all branches. Autosomal tests can identify relatives and unknown family connections from the past five to seven generations, out to roughly sixth cousins. The tests also produce broad biogeographical estimates, presented as percentages that show how your autosomal DNA corresponds to different geographic groups or populations.
One of the main benefits of autosomal tests is the ability to match with living relatives through shared DNA segments. These matches can help corroborate family lore, confirm potential records and provide an additional layer of certainty to your genealogical research. Major testing companies such as Ancestry, FamilyTreeDNA and MyHeritage offer autosomal testing, with prices starting at around €33, alongside large user databases that increase the likelihood of finding relevant matches – the most popular of these in Ireland is Ancestry. Living DNA (our trusted affiliate partner) has a smaller database, but it is growing in popularity in Ireland and the UK.
A F F I L I A T E A D
Autosomal tests have their limitations too. For example, the reliability of the results diminishes for more distant generations. Also, typically you cannot automatically tell which side of your family tree a match belongs to, although you can often work this out by communicating with matches, comparing family trees, consulting genealogical records and using known relatives as anchor matches.
Biogeographical analysis – variously labelled by different companies as “ancient origins”, “ethnicity estimates”, “ethnic origins”, “genetic groups” or “ancestral regions” – can be less precise for Ireland than for some other regions. Many companies simply use the categories “Ireland”, “Irish”, “British and Irish” or “Western European”, rather than pinpointing a specific county, region or province within Ireland. Ancestry does differentiate between these four provinces: Leinster, Munster, Connacht and Ulster & Northern Ireland. Currently, Living DNA’s ancestry test can pinpoint three distinct regions in Ireland, but the company is actively encouraging individuals with known Irish ancestry, particularly in the last three generations, to participate in their research to help improve and expand the accuracy of their regional predictions (find out more here).
Sign up to our newsletter
Biogeographical estimates depend heavily on each company’s reference population, so testing with multiple companies can yield very different results. Likewise, due to the way DNA is inherited, your siblings may receive different results from yours. These estimates should therefore be treated as a guide rather than a definitive measure of your “Irishness”. Often, the biogeographical estimates simply confirm what is already known by the tested individual through documentary research and family tradition. It is important to note that, despite marketing terms like “ancient origins”, these biogeographical estimates do not reveal deep ancient ancestry in the same way as Y-DNA or mtDNA haplogroups (more on haplogroups later) and are essentially just percentage estimates based on modern population reference groups residing in a particular region today.
For most people seeking to trace their Irish family connections within the past 150 years, autosomal testing is the most practical starting point despite its limitations. It is the best choice for anyone who wants to explore both sides of their family tree, connect with living relatives and confirm their Irish roots. Read more about autosomal DNA testing here.
A D V E R T I S E M E N T
Y-chromosome DNA tests for Irish genealogical research
Y-chromosome DNA (Y-DNA) tests focus on the paternal line by examining the Y chromosome, which is passed almost unchanged from father to son. This makes it suitable for men who want to explore their direct male lineage and trace the inheritance of their surname. In Ireland, surnames are typically patrilineal, but not all males who share the same surname are genetically related because many Irish surnames have multiple origins. Y-DNA tests are widely used to clarify how families with similar-sounding surnames are related (e.g. O’Keane, Keane, Kean, Keen, Cane, McCain, O’Cahan, etc). These tests can link individuals to specific “clans” and Y-DNA haplogroups – genetic population groups that indicate the deep ancestral origins and migratory routes of your paternal ancestors.
Y-DNA tests come in different levels or tiers. Three companies currently offer Y-DNA testing: FamilyTreeDNA, Genebase and YSEQ, but FamilyTreeDNA provides the widest range of tests. It also has the largest Y-DNA database and over 12,000 group projects (including lots of Irish surname projects).
Tests are based on the number of Y-DNA markers checked, known as STRs (short tandem repeats). Most people purchasing from FamilyTreeDNA start with the basic 37-marker STR test, which is relatively affordable (currently retailing at $119 USD) and can later be upgraded since the company stores your sample. This basic test enables you to connect with distant paternal-line relatives, while more advanced STR tests, analyzing more markers, provide greater resolution and can identify closer matches within genealogical timeframes.
A D V E R T I S E M E N T
There are also SNP (single nucleotide polymorphisms) tests, which examine individual DNA changes along the Y chromosome, as well as full- or large-scale Y-chromosome sequencing tests, such as FamilyTreeDNA’s Big Y-700 (currently retailing at $449 USD). These tests can detect rare mutations, refine haplogroup assignments and reveal very deep paternal ancestry. In general, the more markers or mutations examined and the more extensive the sequencing, the higher the cost of the test and the more detailed the results.
Y-DNA SNP tests analyze specific SNPs – small changes or mutations in the DNA code on the Y chromosome – to determine a man’s haplogroup, which is represented by a letter-and-number code associated with broad geographic regions. Scientists use haplogroups to study human origins and migration, and have constructed a “phylogenetic tree” that shows how different haplogroups are related. Advanced tests, such as the Big Y-700, examine hundreds of thousands of SNPs on the Y chromosome, which enables the placement of the tested individual precisely on this phylogenetic tree. While haplogroups offer a window into ancient ancestry stretching back thousands of years, they do not identify recent relatives. Many SNP tests include wonderful maps and stories about ancient ancestors, which are fascinating but offer limited practical value for the genealogical researcher.
Some companies test only a limited number of SNPs and predict a likely haplogroup from the results. Our affiliate partner Living DNA provides a basic Y-DNA haplogroup prediction for male customers as part of its ancestry testing services. This shows the likely ancient origins of the paternal line but is not designed for tracing family history.
Please help support
Irish Heritage News
A small independent start-up in West Cork
Give as little as €2
Thank You
It is important to remember that only males can take Y-DNA tests. Still, a woman can explore her paternal line by asking her father, brothers, paternal grandfather, paternal uncles or male cousins from the same line to be tested. Y-DNA testing is ideal for investigating a direct male line and confirming connections between men sharing the same surname. Because Y-DNA changes very slowly over generations, it can provide a window into paternal ancestry stretching back hundreds or even thousands of years, far beyond the reach of autosomal DNA tests. However, Y-DNA tests will typically provide you with fewer matches than an autosomal test.
In short, Y-DNA testing is the best option for men who want to investigate their paternal lineage, connect with living relatives whose Y chromosome is similar to theirs and learn about the migration routes of their ancient paternal ancestors. Different types of Y-DNA tests achieve different results and the level of detail generally reflects the cost of the test.
Mitochondrial DNA tests for Irish genealogical research
Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) tests focus on the matrilineal line: your mother, your mother’s mother (i.e. your maternal grandmother), your maternal grandmother’s mother (i.e. your maternal great-grandmother) and so on. MtDNA is inherited from the mother by all her children, meaning both males and females can take mtDNA tests. However, only females pass mtDNA on to the next generation, and so while a man can take an mtDNA test to investigate his mother’s line, his children inherit their mtDNA from their mother only and so cannot use their mtDNA to investigate their father’s maternal lineage.
A F F I L I A T E A D
Full mtDNA sequence testing is currently only available from FamilyTreeDNA and this company also maintains the largest mtDNA database in the world. The test provides the highest resolution available for genealogical purposes, enabling individuals to trace their direct maternal lineage with great accuracy and connect with others who share a common matrilineal ancestor, though this may be hundreds or even thousands of years in the past – most of your matches will be distant relatives.
MtDNA changes very slowly over generations and can be used to identify mtDNA haplogroups (genetic population groups that indicate the deep ancestral origins and migratory routes of your maternal ancestors). Each mtDNA haplogroup is represented by a letter-and-number code and is linked to specific regions of the world. For example, haplogroup H is the most common in Europe, with about half of the population of Europe belonging to this haplogroup. When your test assigns you to a specific mtDNA haplogroup, it provides information about where your maternal line originated thousands of years ago and offers a window into your deep ancestry, but it does not help you identify recent ancestors.
Aside from FamilyTreeDNA, some other companies provide more limited mtDNA information. For example, our affiliate partner Living DNA includes a basic mitochondrial haplogroup prediction as part of its ancestry testing services.
Sign up to our newsletter
In short, mtDNA testing is most useful for individuals who wish to investigate their direct maternal line, identify living relatives whose mtDNA is similar to theirs and understand their deep maternal ancestry. Most mtDNA matches will be distant relatives and it’s worth noting that mtDNA tests generally generate fewer genealogical leads than Y-DNA tests and autosomal DNA tests.
In summary
The decision about which DNA test to take ultimately depends on the questions you want to answer. For a broad picture of your recent ancestry across both maternal and paternal branches, and to identify living relatives, an autosomal test is the best option. If your goal is to trace your direct paternal line, a Y-DNA test is most suitable, while an mtDNA test is best for exploring your direct maternal line. For those interested in deep ancestry stretching back hundreds or even thousands of years, only Y-DNA and mtDNA tests reliably identify haplogroups. Autosomal tests may sometimes offer rough predictions of maternal or paternal haplogroups, but these are far less precise. Many genealogical researchers find that using a combination of different types of tests provides the most complete picture of their ancestry. Choosing the right testing company also matters, since factors such as the types of tests sold, the size of the database, regional coverage and the quality of the tools can impact how successful you are in addressing your research questions.
A D V E R T I S E M E N T
Whatever test you choose, the results are most valuable when interpreted cautiously and supported by documentary evidence. An understanding of historical context is also crucial. DNA testing can be rewarding, but it should complement rather than replace traditional genealogical research. By choosing the test that’s best suited to meeting your goals and by approaching the results with both curiosity and caution, your journey into your Irish ancestry can be both informative and enlightening.
Advertising Disclaimer: This article contains affiliate links. Irish Heritage News is an affiliate of FindMyPast and Living DNA. We may earn commissions from qualifying purchases.
READ NOW
➤ Irish genealogy news round-up, September 2025
➤ Mass grave in Pennsylvania could contain remains of over 100 Irish railroad workers
➤ Expert guide to Irish census records available for free download ahead of 1926 census release
➤ New Irish newspaper database now live with searchable records from 1772 to 1900
➤ Two seasons of Sloinne, TG4’s Irish surname series, now available to watch online
